Independent87 rooms · mid-sizeBuilt 2016
The Whitby Hotel
★★★★★9.0 224 reviews18 West 56Th Street · 15 min walk to Times Square




55 photos
At a glance
Against the 42 five-star luxury hotels in New York.
| This hotel | Typical | |
|---|---|---|
| Guest rating | 9.0 | 8.6 |
| Rooms | 87 | 165 |
| Building | 2016 | 1997 |
| Walk to the centre | 15 min | 25 min |
| Independent | Yes | 12 of 42 |
Rated a little higher than most five-star luxury hotels in New York, and smaller and newer than most.
by guest rating
A mid-size independent hotel built in 2016, rated a little higher than most five-star luxury hotels in New York. Guests value the staff first, then the rooms and the central location.
Written from the facts on this page: the hotel’s data and its 6 most recent reviews.
What gives it character
The facts that set it apart from other premium hotels.
Smaller than most five-star hotels in New York.
Not part of a hotel group.
A building from 2016, newer than most nearby.
Rated a little higher than the typical five-star hotel here.
Room service, a bar and a restaurant among its services.
What guests write about
Topics in the 6 most recent reviews. Reworded, never quoted.
In short
In short, guests praise the staff, who are described as attentive and kind, and the rooms, which they find comfortable and well decorated. The central location and the bar and lounge come up less often.
Summary of the reviews above; no review is quoted.
Rooms & suites
6 room types, 3 of them suites.
What the house offers
From the hotel’s facility list.
Dining
- In-room breakfast
- Restaurant
- Snack bar
- Bar/ Lounge area
- Special diet menus
Wellness
- Massage
- Fitness centre
Service
- Room service
- Car hire
- Laundry
- Dry cleaning
- Welcome drink
Outdoors
- Terrace
Where it is
15 min walk to Times Square, measured from the hotel’s map position.
- The St. Regis2 min
- A Choice Nanny4 min
- 230 Fifth Avenue5 min
- Late Night with Jimmy Fallon8 min
- 57th Street8 min
- Richard Rodgers Theatre16 min
Walking times are estimates from the map, not from the hotel’s advert.
How it compares
Against the 3 nearest premium hotels.
| Hotel | Stars | Rating | Rooms | Built | Independent | Spa | To the centre |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Whitby Hotel | 5★ | 9.0 (224) | 87 | 2016 | Yes | — | 15 min |
| The Peninsula New York | 5★ | 8.7 (561) | 195 | 1905 | Group | Yes | 15 min |
| The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park | 5★ | 8.0 (221) | 257 | 1929 | Group | Yes | 17 min |
| Thompson Central Park New York | 5★ | 8.2 (1,312) | 613 | 1981 | Group | — | 13 min |
Questions guests ask
Is it an independent hotel?
Yes. The Whitby Hotel is independent and is not part of a hotel group. — hotel data
How old is the building?
Built in 2016. The building dates from 2016, making it newer than most five-star luxury hotels in New York. — hotel data
Is the service praised?
Yes, often. Four of the six reviews that mention it praise the staff for being courteous, attentive and kind. — guest reviews
Does it have suites?
Yes. Three of the six room types are suites, including one with a terrace and one with a bathtub. — room list
Are pets allowed?
Yes. Pets are allowed at The Whitby Hotel. — hotel data
Good to know
- Check-in
- From 15:00
- Check-out
- Until 12:00
- Pets
- Allowed
- Lift
- Yes
- Floors
- 16


